 |
Your M.D. will recommend Chiropractic treatment - if he or she has kept up to date on medical research!
Numerous studies have validated the efficacy and safety of Chiropractic over
the last 20 years. In progressive medical circles, this research has
forged a beneficial cooperative relationship between M.D.'s and D.C.'s
(Doctors of Chiropractic).
Many chiropractors regularly work
with medical doctors now, to provide safe and effective care for neck
pain, back pain, headaches, carpal tunnel syndrome, and other painful
conditions. (To meet some M.D.'s who use this approach, go to: http://www.akashacenter.com )
In
fact, the respected medical journal, The Journal of Family Practice,
published an article in 1992 listing "Guidelines for Identifying a
Competent Chiropractor", to help M.D.'s find chiropractors to whom they
could feel confident referring their patients. Those guidelines are:
1. Treatment mainly for musculoskeletal disorders
2. Doesn't do routine x-rays on every patient
3. Doesn't extend duration of treatment unnecessarily
4. Writes a response to a medical referral and outlines evaluation and therapy
5. Doesn't charge "front end" lump sum for whole treatment program
6. Graduated from CCE accredited school
7. Willing to have M.D. visit office to observe treatment
8. Good feedback from patient on care given
(Reference: Curtis, Bove. The JOURNAL OF FAMILY PRACTICE, 1992; 35(5): 551-555 Guidelines for Identifying A Competent Chiropractor)
Another
medical voice in support of chiropractic treatment came from George
Waddell, M.D., himself an orthopedic surgeon, and the chief medical
officer for the World Health Organization in 1997. He reported on low
back pain treatments in the another prestigious medical journal, Spine:
"Traditional medical treatment...has failed. Bed rest: (as a
treatment) should die as soon as it can. Avoid if possible. Physical
Therapy: there is no adequate evidence of effectiveness. Spinal
manipulation: one of the two treatments of proven value., The past ten
years has produced a lot of solid scientific evidence to support the
value of manipulation." ( Reference: Waddell G, MD. The Back Pain
Revolution. ... SPINE 1997; 22(14):1545- 1552. )
But sadly, old prejudices and misinformation die hard.
A
study published in SPINE, three years after the article mentioned
above, surveyed medical doctors about their beliefs on the
effectiveness of non-surgical treatment for low back pain. The doctors
surveyed said that only 3% had recommended spinal manipulation for
their patients with low back pain or sciatica.
For the same
conditions, these doctors expressed a belief in the effectiveness of
Physical Therapy (81-93%), bedrest longer than 3 days (72%) and TENS
units (74%). Yet reputable studies published in respected medical
journals have compared the outcomes of those therapies to the outcomes
of chiropractic treatment, with chiropractic results much better than
Physical Therapy, Bedrest, or TENS units. (Click on "Got Proof?" from
Home page for details.)
In fact, the research has been so
compelling, that the governments of the United States and Canada, have
both released reports supporting chiropractic treatment of low back
pain over medical treatment. (Low back pain is
the condition most researched with regard to chiropractic spinal
manipulation, since it is the 3rd most common ailment for which
patients see a doctor.)
From the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service:
Bigos
et al, Acute Low Back Problems in Adults. AHCPR* Clinical Guidelines
No. 14: AHCPR, December 1994. (800) 358-9295 Recommends Spinal
Manipulation as manual therapy for symptomatic relief and functional
improvement of the back. States "Surgery has been found to be helpful
in only 1 in 100 cases of low back pain", and even a lot of back pain
by itself doesn't mean you need surgery. Lists Potential Harms and Side
Effects of Bed Rest, and states "Prolonged bed rest for more than 4
days may lead to debilitation and is not recommended for treating acute
low back problems...The majority of low back patients will not require
bed rest." (P.53)
from the Manga Report for the Ontario Ministry of Health, (Canadian government) 1998:
Chiropractic
care is safer, more effective, reduces both disability and chronicity.
Chiropractic reduces the spiralling of health care costs which occurs
in the medical system. (copy of Manga report available (800) 622-6309)
From the Quebec Task Force on Whiplash-Associated Disorders (W.A.D.), 1995:
"manipulation
and mobilization by trained persons and active exercises are useful in
grade II and III W.A.D., but prolonged use of cervical collars, rest or
inactivity probably prolongs disability. ( Reference: Spitzer, Quebec
Task Force on Whiplash-Associated Disorders (W.A.D.), 1995; 20(8S):
1S-73S )